From The Boat, We Swim

Updated: Mar 17, 2023
I stared at it for what felt like an eternity, and somewhere between forever and a split second, my mind caught up to what my gut already knew. I wasn’t hallucinating. Straight down the middle, jagged edges and unformed words. The sanctity of my diary had been tarnished, and there was only one suspect. With shaking hands, I strategised my approach, but while my brain cautioned me to ‘think’, my legs were already walking toward the kitchen. A seething hot flame burned inside of me. All I could hear was my heartbeat, all I could sense was rage.
She screamed, I screamed. We cried. My dad sat watching on the outskirts, mediating silently like an impartial umpire. Her error was picking up the diary, her guilt left a ripped page behind. An unwashable mistake, her hands were red.
In the bathetic aftermath, the flames licked my tears dry as I melodramatically watched my diary turn to ash. I bet my family wheelbarrow never expected to double as a fire pit.
My poor mother. Terrorising her eldest daughter while trying to protect her. I guess everything is hard the first time, no matter what it is.
The thing I didn't understand at the time about my mum and her self-proclaimed ‘Lady Macbeth’ moment is that it had far less to do with me than my egocentric teenage brain allowed me to understand.
For at the same time I was experimenting with defiance and risk-taking, my mother was stuck counting all of the ways her body had betrayed her. A lifetime of impeccable eating, aerobic instructing, dancing, and never drinking was not enough to halt lesions forming on her brain. The spiral that comes with the diagnosis of an incurable illness is something I am grateful to not have ever been forced to understand.
When life is full of unrelenting twists, how can the confusion of growing up end?
While “Living with Multiple-sclerosis” literature started to fill our bookshelves and frequent our browser history, my parents had their targets set on securing another diagnosis.
My sister and I could not have been scripted as more different people. While I was viciously outgoing, overwhelmingly confident and coasting through school, my dear little sister was barely surviving. Everything was a struggle; the struggle to make and hold friendships, the struggle to understand basic instructions or even facial expressions, the struggle to eat foods that were not yellow-hued or sugar-filled. Directions, time, money - all foreign languages that sat on the tip of her shy tongue, never quite forming the necessary familiarity to be as autonomous as I naturally, effortlessly was.
As the eldest daughter, I always felt responsible. As the eldest female on both sides of the family, I was responsible. A role model, the black sheep, always in trouble, questioned, probed. A microscope was held on me whenever I would wear a short skirt or come to Christmas with makeup on. My decision to have a boyfriend was weighed on by every adult in my family, every step I took was judged by the court of uncles, aunties and my parent’s friends. I was both the leader and the one who had to be kept under check.
Without my guardians realising it, I was pushed to grow up quickly, which is something I naively prided myself on. I thought ageing would give me the freedom I craved, the autonomy I needed. But slowly, I awoke to all that had been happening around me while I was in the slumber of my teenage years.
My sister was thirteen when she was diagnosed with autism, a diagnosis that meant she could finally get the support that she needed, but also a confirmation of all of the life-affirming support she had so far been missing.
Simultaneously, my mother was pushed into a medication schedule that left her feeling ill every second day.
Begrudgingly, this was all happening while I was fighting for my right to make my own bad decisions and not hear a word of advice or scrutiny from any unknowing, ridiculous thinking, overly controlling adult in my life.
Objectively, my struggle for freedom and choice pales in comparison to the struggles of my mother and sister. But in reality, we were all suffering from the lack of the same single thing.
Control. A luxury few can afford.
When you’re the eldest daughter, which both my mother and I are, your decisions don’t belong to you as much as you deserve. Neither do your actions or the outcome of those actions. It is only now, as a twenty-something, that I understand my actions were not just my own, but to those holding judgement, a reflection of my mother’s.
‘Our family is in a boat, and when one of us steps out of line, a hole goes in the boat and we all sink’. A last dash attempt to help my young mind understand the implications of my actions. Also, the most annoying of my mother’s analogies. I hated it every time she said this, lips puckered, eyes rolling. It fueled my desire to rebel, but something about my mother’s desperation, something that I couldn’t quite grasp, kept me in line.
Beyond snarky remarks and abrupt attitude, in my formative years, I couldn’t articulate why but the notion that my family’s boat could be tipped by my teenage urge to run wild was absolutely ludicrous to me.
It breaks my heart that my mum has grown up feeling this way. How exhausting it must be to grow up in a glass home while all of your judges are holding rocks. A generational fate that the eldest daughter is doomed to fall into.
And now? Only now. Now that I understand we’re burdened by the same script, we can talk. We can talk like friends, in love with our relationship. Choosing to understand each other. We are guided by all we have experienced, understood and learnt through each other.
As much as I was innocently in my outrageous teenage years, my mum was also living through her parent-teenage years, working it all out for the first time. Balancing a home, two daughters with needs on opposite ends of the spectrum, and the body that birthed us into this existence. Balancing the expectations of being the eldest daughter.
Now, mum and I talk and share and philosophise together. We reflect and unpack and discuss. We’re a team, not by force or because the cosmos put us in each other's lives, but because we have made the choice to brave life together. Now, we’re just two girls, born into the reckonings of being the eldest and a woman and scrutinised through the loving yet unforgiving world of family expectations.
Thirty years apart, yet one and the same.
From the eldest daughter, to her mother.
Inspired by the anthology, Growing Up In Australia.
Comments