top of page

Who You Are, Not What You Know

Writer: Kyra Hatzikosmidis
Kyra Hatzikosmidis
Nov 17, 2021
14 min read

Updated: May 16, 2023

How the current structures of education hinder us from teaching and learning.


There are a string of highly poignant images burnt into my brain from my Year 12 examination week. Perhaps because there is photographic evidence, or perhaps because I spent the month in a dissociative stressed state, I can see myself from a third-person point of view, with fists full of hair in my hands, surrounded by papers face down on the hardwood floors feeling equal parts relief and angst over the exams completed and those still to come. For my final months of school, I demanded silence, support, advice and comfort from my family. I balanced the pulls of my social life with my need for academic validation. I experienced anxiety, an experience shared by approximately 80% of Australian students, that later developed into an anxiety disorder that has sat with me like a lead-filled cloud ever since. I got into the course I was studying for, then, five years later, realised I couldn’t care less about the industry. Despite sixteen years of schooling, I realised I wanted nothing to do with what I had been conditioned to work toward.


I am one of the lucky ones. I am naturally academically inclined, my parents both have higher education qualifications, we are a middle-class family and I had any resource I needed at my fingertips. I had the security to perform to the best of my ability, whatever that may be, because my family’s socioeconomic status and standing in society meant that I could take my time working myself out. When I decided to leave my full-time job to pursue teaching at the age of twenty-five, I didn’t need to worry about financial stability as my living conditions allowed space for trial and error. After all, the system in which we exist is geared distinctly to ensure people like me can succeed. However, not everyone is like me - not even the people I live with. My parents grew up in immigrant households, had to support their parents while finishing school and at the age I am now they secured jobs that they have not left until this day. Their allowance for trial and error was far smaller than mine. I am a complete outlier in my household, especially in comparison to my sister who has autism and a learning disability. The system was not built for her the way it was built for me. Yet even so, because of our parents, my sister is still luckier than most.


And so begs the question - who does the current structure of the school system serve? What of the students who struggle with literacy, have additional learning needs or come from low socioeconomic households? What does it mean to serve the nation's best interests over the individual? This paper will critically analyse Australia’s high school curriculum and ATAR system and how they systematically fail Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders and students with additional learning needs and how a divorce from standardised testing may be the solution.


Curriculum Woes


When considering my household as a sample of the student population - academically competent, migrants, learners of English as an additional language, those with additional learning needs and those suffering mental illness or have a diagnosed disability - there are several fundamental problems with the current structure of the school curriculum that present themselves. If the pressure placed on students by the curriculum and standardised testing is unhealthy for students like me, who are capable, then its effects on students who experience educational barriers could be detrimental. As the system currently stands, both students and teachers are cogs in the unrelenting machine that is the standardised curriculum. The Victorian Curriculum, which is a step beyond the Australian Curriculum, is jam-packed with content, standards and requirements. Victoria’s goal to become the ‘Education State’ led it to innovate the curriculum in 2015, which raised the standard for what is taught in the state’s schools, solidifying its place as the most thorough and content-heavy curriculum countrywide. While this brought a heightened air of prestige to the Victorian school system, it also added to an already overloaded set of academic expectations that equally harm students and teachers. With an overloaded curriculum comes the sacrifice of quality for quantity, of not only the content taught but the amount students actually take on board. And thus, school becomes just another cog in the capitalist machine, embedding in students the notion that the speed and quantity of content produced are more important than the process that goes into the content’s production.


What is taught in schools is not the issue. It is the structure in which it is taught; the pigeonholing of capabilities, the smothering of creativity and a suffocatingly fast pace that leaves too many students behind. Although it is not intentional, the culmination of the delivery, pace and cumulative standardised examinations squander the potential of students. As Sir Ken Robinson (2011) explored, the trajectory of education goes ‘waist up’ - that is to say, that by the time students have reached their final years of high school, students’ talents, interests and creativity are tapered into a single goal; high grades. As a result, too many students are left with fewer ways to express their cognition, creativity and self-exploration because the view of intelligence is measured by one’s academic ability, which disenfranchises students from finding pride in their own abilities. Even with the inclusion of creative arts subjects in the senior curriculum, the heightened importance attached to job-making subjects that feeds directly into the school-to-job pipeline ideology is difficult to ignore.


ATAR Over Passion


Everything taught in primary school is geared toward preparing students for high school, and everything taught in high school is designed to ensure success when students sit their VCE exams. Then, these examinations are explicitly designed to turn thirteen years of academic and personal development into a singular weighted score, ATAR, that will, in turn, funnel students into their University degree of choice - but only if their ATAR is good enough. Formerly, the fundamental goal of education was to build a lifetime of worthwhile knowledge and cognition in our students, but now the emphasis on the attainment of knowledge as the goal has wavered. When asked about their perceptions of the ATAR system, students dubbed it as a means to measure how well they can memorise, regurgitate and rote learn information, a way to ‘stress’ students and as a crusher for passion, as 37% of students opted for subjects that would allow them to get a better grade rather than those they were interested in. ATAR is used by universities to predict how successful a student will be and high schools secure more funding depending on how many students graduate with an ATAR fit for university. Taking this into consideration, it can be inferred that the purpose of modern education is no longer about lifelong, quality learning. Rather, it all comes back to money, funding and the illusion of prestige that schools and universities use their students’ labour to attain. Studies have unveiled that ATAR is a weak predictor of success in higher education. This shows the inability for schools to effectively differentiate teaching and assessments to capture the capabilities of all students. With these ulterior motives driving the structure of our school system, it is not only unethical to attribute ATAR to intelligence or capability but ineffective.


Good Little Workers


Recognising students as people beyond their grades and school fees is instrumental to examining the systemic barriers that the current educational structure houses. In order to examine how Cuban’s (2014) sentiment of school as a cog in the capitalist machine manifests in reality with further implications, one must recognise that the hierarchy of subjects is not merely symbolic. Rather, this hierarchy (science at the top, creativity at the bottom) has been solidified most recently by the Coalition government’s ‘job relevant’ uni fee price hike. The educational business model, from school to university to job is no secret, yet the interaction that is embedded in our students to apply it to their learning requires consideration. One can deduce from the current state of education that society has forgotten all of the things education can offer that does not involve work. The Coalition’s ‘job relevant’ fee adjustments have increased the cost of humanities and creative arts degrees by 113% on the basis that these degrees do not funnel people into jobs. Other than devaluing student interests, this strengthens the capitalist threads that our society is built on; and so the production line continues. Students are coerced into advancing the capitalist society simply by embarking on their learning trajectory. Capitalism, by definition, requires someone to be at the bottom so that others can be at the top, which is emulated in the ATAR’s ranking system. Students are commodified and categorised throughout their schooling and into their careers, leaving those who are capable to excel and those who are not to progressively fall behind as the stakes continue to rise.


The Pedagogical Other


Success in education can often be attributed to two things: the literacy competence and socioeconomic status of a student’s parents. If a student’s parents are poorly educated, it is much harder (not impossible) for the student to enter university and achieve what is socially deemed as successful. Students learning English as an Additional Language (EAL) start behind those who are native English speakers because they do not have the same access to literacy support at home. However, due to the global recognition of the Western education system, EAL students are culturally pre-conditioned to achieve levels of success within the Australian framework of learning. This cannot be said of all EAL students, especially for those who not only come from low socioeconomic and low literacy households and are on the outer banks of society.


Migrant and refugee-background families come to Australia actively seeking education and job opportunities (as well as safety and stability). However, for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander (ATSI) students (who are considered EAL students) school is symbolic of the continued and inescapable Eurocentric, capitalist oppression for many Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander students and families. ATSI students are seen as guests in their own country and thus have been generationally coerced into the standards, expectations and culture of colonial Australian systems with few other options. With consideration to the VCE and higher education success rates of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander students, it is clear that the attempt to assimilate Aboriginal people to excel in Britain’s Australia was an abject failure. The “stark reality” is that ATSI enrolment and completion rates across VCE and higher education are “significantly lower” than the population parity rate. In fact, between the years of 2018 and 2019, only 36% of Indigenous students in Victoria completed their VCE, despite increased initiatives and support programs to ensure that they would (Australian Bureau of Statistics, 2020). Furthermore, Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander students continue to fall behind the national average despite increased participation rates, which are low in themselves. The poor enrolment, retention and completion rates are a reflection of the education system’s systemic failure to create meaningful learning experiences for ATSI students, leaving them to suffer poor self-esteem and, consequently, poor learning outcomes that impact generations of learners within their community.


Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander students exist between two cultural environments; of their school and of their home. The friction between identity, culture and standards of Australian English spoken often cause Aboriginal students to fall behind in their learning before they have even begun. ATSI students are often misdiagnosed with literacy learning disabilities which not only lessens their academic output as expectations placed upon them are dropped but also impacts their confidence and view of themselves as competent learners. The language disparities between Australian Aboriginal English (AAE) and Standard Australian English (SAE), start in primary school and continue throughout high school as compliance expectations increase. The invalidity of AAE is increasingly solidified because of standardised tests like NAPLAN (Numeracy and Literacy) and the end of high school examinations, which pushes ATSI students into supplementary educational pathways like VCAL and VET instead of VCE and ultimately higher education. Because there are inherently conflicting values regarding achieving self-actualisation and success as a learner, the self-esteem and motivation of these students diminish. However, data on Indigenous students transitioning from high school to higher education should not be used to “fix” the problem, but rather to push society to reconsider what is deemed as success. Success is defined differently for every person on this earth, we cannot just package an idea of success and impose it on people and in turn make them feel like inadequate societal misfits.


The Additional Learning Needs Paradox


Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander students are not the only cohort of learners who are left behind due to the stranglehold standardised testing and the fast-paced curriculum have over education. Considering that one in six Australians have a disability, an average of four students per class of twenty-five, there is an indefinite need to examine to what extent the current structure of the school is beneficial. During my first placement, a Year 7 student asked me to tie up their shoelaces after every Dance class. This same student didn't know how to close the blinds or even read a simple sentence from the lesson’s worksheet. While this student is an extreme case of an undiagnosed disability, they are not the exception. In this Year 7 class alone there were two students on modified learning plans and three students who needed additional learning support despite not having a formal diagnosis. This equated to 25% of the class population overall; and those were just the students with needs that were obvious. The level of intervention these students need within the classroom cannot be met through differentiation alone. There is an expectation for students with additional learning needs to just fit in with the existing school structure which simply does not suffice nor benefit their learning trajectory.


Without parental advocacy and consent, students with suspected additional learning needs cannot be given the support they require to learn. This is because students cannot sit modified examinations unless they have a formal diagnosis to show that they need it. These parameters place barriers for so many students who need less conventional means to achieve academic success, and for students who are “not disabled enough”, not even parental advocacy can get their needs met. Typical of females with autism, my sister Anastasia, was one of the students who were “not disabled enough” to have additional learning support. When asked to reflect on her time in school, my sister cried recounting all of the times she was picked on for not completing her work as fast as the other students. It was not until Year 8 that my sister's additional needs were recognised, nine years into her educational journey. This left her with poor self-esteem, feelings of extreme vulnerability and, if our parents had not been so diligent, she would have been left to fall further and further behind academically, an experience that is unfortunately common. Due to how integral parental advocacy is to ensure students with additional needs are supported, it is devastating that only some success is seen with even educated parents from high socioeconomic background. Thus meeting the standard of advocacy expected by schools ultimately creates a larger gap of equality in education and consequently society as a whole.


Taking Steps Forward


The fast-paced curriculum, cumulative standardised examinations and implications for learners, who do not match the ideal learner’s image, pose a series of challenges in the modern classroom that have not been effectively dealt with on a large scale. The first measure that should be taken to create a learning environment that promotes learning overproduction is to actively curtail the importance of standardised tests. Students ask “Is this important?” linking their learning to a test. Instead, we need to tap into promoting learning for personal growth and encourage our students to be active life-learners. The constant conflation between what is learnt and what is assessed diminishes the importance of everything that is not on the test thus minimising the breadth of learning that can be achieved. In a bid to break the attachment between learning and assessment, >redacted< High School has removed assessments completely from Year 7 through to Year 9. As the fourth top-performing public high school in Victoria, >redacted< High School is far from throwing the ATAR system out, but their teaching and learning model for their junior school has taken the right step toward ensuring students recognise all learning, not just what they are assessed on, as important.


>redacted< High School’s continua should become common practice across the board as it allows for all students to achieve success in their learning without the pressure of performing on a single given day or assessment. It also provides teachers with an opportunity to assess against the curriculum by pulling data from conversations, worksheets, questions asked and small pieces of work submitted. For all students, those who experience anxiety, have additional learning needs or are from non-Standard Australian English speaking backgrounds, >redacted< offers a continuous learning system that provides more low-risk high-impact opportunities, to not only demonstrate learning but also engage students in more meaningfully learning. Anastasia, my sister, considered that the support her teachers showed her revolved around helping her finish work on time rather than produce work she was proud of. A system like the continua would also allow students to work on one project, theme or scope of work for longer. Implementing the continua into the senior classes would also allow students to achieve success over a more evenly weighted period of time. Despite Covid-19 and lockdowns, and the current cohort citing mental health and low motivation, the Year 12s of this same cohort will be sitting their examinations despite having spent their senior years of high school learning from home. As it currently stands it is as if society has collectively agreed to bury heads in the sand, keeping the status quo without taking the opportunity to improve and redesign the system to create more meaningful learning experiences.


There will always be students who cannot speak up or will not admit feeling less confident. This is why the curriculum, and structure of teaching should be opened up to allow for not only more room for success, but a wider interpretation of what success should look like. The sentiment that teachers exist to grow the minds of the new generation of leaders drives the motivational content that pre-service teachers are fed to inspire them into the profession. If it is true, which it is, that we are growing the minds of the leaders-to-come in our classrooms, then we should be placing emphasis on the exploration of learning and growth rather than pigeonholing capabilities into completing tasks and scoring high on tests.


As it stands, the current structure of the school system is designed to teach students to present ideas in a constrained format, to go off into university and finally a job. Instead, education should be inspiring and school should be a place of self-discovery and passion, rather than of stress, alienation and competition. In order to serve the nation, we must first serve the individual and serving the individual means meeting each individual student where they are so that we can empower their learning beyond a grade.





References


Australian Bureau of Statistics. (2020, December 4). Education Statistics for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peoples, 2018-19 financial year. Australian Bureau of Statistics; Australian Bureau of Statistics. https://www.abs.gov.au/statistics/people/aboriginal-and-torres-strait-islander-peoples/education-statistics-aboriginal-and-torres-strait-islander-peoples/latest-release


Autism Awareness Australia. (2020, December 16). Girls and Autism. Autism Awareness Australia. https://www.autismawareness.com.au/could-it-be-autism/autism-and-girls/


Burke, M. M., & Hodapp, R. M. (2016). The nature correlates, and conditions of parental

advocacy in special education. Exceptionality, 24(3), 137-150. https://doi.org/10.1080/09362835.2015.1064412


Chivers, S. (2012) Twice-exceptionality in the classroom. Journal of Student Engagement: Education Matters, 2(1), 26-29. https://ro.uow.edu.au/jseem/vol2/iss1/5


Connell, R., Welch, A., Vickers, M., Foley, D., Bagnell, N., Hayes, D., Proctor, H., Sriprakash, A., & Campbell, C. (2013). Education, change and society. ProQuest Ebook Central https://ebookcentral.proquest.com


Cuban, L. (2014, May 8). Schools as factories: metaphors that stick. Larry Cuban on School Reform and Classroom Practice; Larry Cuban on School Reform and Classroom Practice. https://larrycuban.wordpress.com/2014/05/08/schools-as-factories-metaphors-that-stick/


Dobson, I. (2015). A profile of the aboriginal and torres strait islander higher education student population. Nteu.org.au. https://www.nteu.org.au/article/A-profile-of-the-Aboriginal-and-Torres-Strait-Islander-higher-education-student-population-17909


Dobinson, T., & Buchori, S. (2016). Catering for eal/d students’ language needs in mainstream classes: early childhood teachers’ perspectives and practices in one Australian setting. The Australian Journal of Teacher Education, 41(2), 32–52. https://doi.org/10.14221/ajte.2016v41n2.3


Educators. (2019, October 23). Gen Zs Tell Why It’s Time To Dump The ATAR. YouthSense. https://youthsense.com.au/educators/gen-z-why-dump-atar/


Headspace. (2017). Majority of Aussie students stressed, depressed | headspace. Headspace.org.au. https://headspace.org.au/blog/majority-of-aussie-students-stressed-depressed/


Horton, A. P. (2020). Why Australia is doubling fees for arts degrees. Bbc.com. https://www.bbc.com/worklife/article/20200728-why-australia-is-charging-more-to-study-history


Hunter, F. (2018, December 9). “Too much being taught”: Tehan says national curriculum is overcrowded. The Sydney Morning Herald; The Sydney Morning Herald. https://www.smh.com.au/politics/federal/too-much-being-taught-tehan-says-national-curriculum-is-overcrowded-20181209-p50l5s.html


Hyde, M., Carpenter, L., & Dole, S. (2017). Diversity, inclusion and engagement 3e. ProQuest Ebook Central https://ebookcentral.proquest.com


Lowell, A., & Devlin, B. (2010, April 23). Miscommunication between Aboriginal students and their non-aboriginal teachers in a bilingual school. Language Culture and Curriculum. https://www-tandfonline-com.ezproxy2.acu.edu.au/doi/abs/10.1080/07908319808666563


Messinis, G. (2015, May 12). ATAR found to be a poor predictor of how well students do at uni. The Conversation. https://theconversation.com/atar-found-to-be-a-poor-predictor-of-how-well-students-do-at-uni-41677


Morgan, B. (2019). Beyond the guest paradigm: eurocentric education and aboriginal peoples in nsw. Handbook of Indigenous Education, 111–128. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-10-3899-0_60


‌Papadopoulos, T. (2016, July 11). What does the new Victorian Curriculum mean for you? Education Matters Magazine. https://www.educationmattersmag.com.au/new-victorian-curriculum-fact-sheet-jacaranda/


Pitman, T. (2019, November 26). What actually is an ATAR? First of all it’s a rank, not a score. The Conversation. https://theconversation.com/what-actually-is-an-atar-first-of-all-its-a-rank-not-a-score-126594


‌Robinson, S. K. (2011). Transcript of “do schools kill creativity?” Ted.com; TED Talks. https://www.ted.com/talks/sir_ken_robinson_do_schools_kill_creativity/transcript


‌Seyfort, S. (2021, October 14). Explained: how VCE exams will work this year during Victoria’s delta outbreak. @9News; 9News. https://www.9news.com.au/national/coronavirus-victoria-how-vce-exams-will-work-for-year-11-and-12-students-during-the-delta-outbreak/60b0219e-142f-41c0-b31d-88e12061b638


Welch, A. R., Königsberg, P., Rochecouste, J., & Glenys Collard. (2015). Aboriginal education in Australia: Policies, Problems, Prospects. ResearchGate; unknown. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/305458158_Aboriginal_Education_in_Australia_Policies_Problems_Prospects


 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
Fight or Fight: From an Australian Woman.

I do not come here as a victim, despite two in five women, Australian women, becoming a victim before the age of fifteen. I do not come here as a daughter, a wife, a girlfriend – as it matters not wha

 
 
 
On Beauty: The Price of Forgetting

If you asked me to recall a happy memory, it would flood into my mind in a hazy blur of joyful hues. Both recent and from childhood, the...

 
 
 
From The Boat, We Swim

I stared at it for what felt like an eternity, and somewhere between forever and a split second, my mind caught up to what my gut already...

 
 
 

Comments


let's get started

© 2020 By Kyra Hatzikosmidis. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page